ESG generation gap is widest ever as performance expectations fall
The “G” of ESG has leapfrogged the “E” for the first time among private investors.
Only 31% of investors over 65 years old consider ESG when investing, compared to 65% of those under 45, according to the newly released ESG Attitudes Tracker from the Association of Investment Companies (AIC) 1. While this generation gap has persisted since the Tracker was launched in 2021, it is now the widest it has ever been at 34 percentage points, compared to 32 percentage points in 2025.
The overall percentage of investors who say they consider ESG is now 45%, down from 53% last year and an all-time low.
Since launching this research in 2021 we’ve seen the initial excitement around ESG investing fade. The main factor has been poor performance and depressed expectations for future performance, but there’s also confusion about what ESG stands for and how it’s incorporated into investing.
Nick Britton, Research Director of the Association of Investment Companies
Source: AIC ESG Attitudes Tracker. % of private investors who consider ESG when investing.
ESG investing is increasingly associated with poor performance among both private investors and intermediaries (advisers and wealth managers). Only 16% of private investors think ESG investing will improve performance, compared to double that number (32%) who think it will hinder performance. Sentiment among intermediaries is even more pessimistic, with 11% saying ESG will improve returns and 60% expecting it to worsen them.
Nevertheless, 63% of private investors say they have at least some allocation to sustainable funds, while 92% of intermediaries recommend sustainable funds to clients.
More facts and figures on the ESG generation gap can be found at the bottom of this release, along with quotes from younger and older investors.
Nick Britton, Research Director of the Association of Investment Companies (AIC), said: “Since launching this research in 2021 we’ve seen the initial excitement around ESG investing fade. The main factor has been poor performance and depressed expectations for future performance, but there’s also confusion about what ESG stands for and how it’s incorporated into investing.
“What we haven’t seen before is such a big generation gap between investors under 45 and those aged 65 or more. This isn’t because older investors care less about sustainability – it’s often important to them in their everyday life. But most find the notion of ‘ESG investing’ less appealing. By contrast, younger investors are often interested in making investments that align with their values and are much more likely to be fans of ESG investing.”
“G” leapfrogs “E”
In another key finding, governance has overtaken environmental factors in terms of importance to private investors. Just over two-fifths (41%) of investors say that governance issues are important to them when investing, compared to under two-fifths (37%) who say that environmental issues are important, with 29% finding social issues important.
Source: AIC ESG Attitudes Tracker. % of private investors who find each issue important.
Transparency and disclosure is the most important ESG issue to private investors, with 62% rating it as important. The joint second most important issues are climate change and human rights, each rated as important by 42% of those surveyed.
The impact of Trump
Investors are largely unmoved by President Trump’s hostile attitude to ESG investing. About two-thirds of private investors (65%) say that Trump has had no impact on their attitude to ESG investing, while 21% say it has made them more favourable towards it and 7% say they have become less favourable.
One private investor commented: “Trump has made me more determined to go even harder on moving my money into sustainability. It almost feels like I personally need to increase things to temper some of that damage that he is causing.”
A discretionary fund manager said: “Trump has definitely knocked sentiment, the whole ‘drill baby drill’ was obviously not great for the sector. I think there is impact at the moment but I don’t think it will last. Most of my clients don’t have a particularly high view of his opinions so they are unlikely to be influenced.”
Exploring the ESG generation gap
There’s a clear split between the under-45s and those over 65 when it comes to a range of ESG attitudes.
Two-thirds (66%) of those under 45 say that they are “fans” of investments that consider environmental, social and governance factors, versus only 30% of those over 65.
Older investors are more likely to believe that ESG investing is “woke”, with 28% holding this view compared to only 10% of those under 45.
And they are more pessimistic about future performance prospects, with only 12% agreeing that ESG investing will outperform over the longer term, compared to 35% of those under 45.
But when it comes to attitudes to sustainability in everyday life, the generation gap is smaller. More than half (58%) of those over 65 say that sustainability is important to them in their everyday life, compared to 70% of those under 45.
One 36-year old investor said: “Sustainability to me is just long-term thinking. It’s about having an ethical attitude toward the people you are dealing with. It’s important that companies think about who they are investing with, not just primarily focusing on financial outputs.”
A 72-year-old investor commented: “I have always been a bit sceptical, there are companies out there like Shell and BP, we know they work and my view is I am restricting my universe of stocks by investing in ESG. At the end of the day it’s not up to me to make laws for companies to follow, that’s up to the government and public opinion. These companies are highly likely to be in line with the law.”
- The ESG Attitudes Tracker is an annual sentiment survey of attitudes to ESG and sustainability commissioned by the Association of Investment Companies (AIC) and conducted by Research in Finance. This release covers findings from the sixth wave of the research, which consisted of online surveys of 400 private investors and 200 intermediaries (120 financial advisers and 80 wealth managers), supplemented by 12 in-depth interviews, six with private investors and six with intermediaries. The fieldwork was conducted between 8 July and 4 September 2026. More details on the methodology are available from the AIC.