Right place, wrong stocks: Pacific Horizon wrong-foots China switch
Pacific Horizon (PHI ) returns took a hit after mis-steps in China, but it said says macro headwinds are ‘receding’.
The £681m portfolio of Asia Pacific stocks, excluding Japan and Australia, has extended its poor run as Baillie Gifford’s growth strategy remains out of favour.
In the year to end of July, the net asset value (NAV) including dividends was 8.3%, significantly behind the 17.1% MSCI All Country Asia ex Japan index. The share price was even more lacklustre, up just 6.4%.
Earnings per share also fell to 2.3p, from 3.8p last year, due to increased cost of borrowing as gearing moved from nothing to 5% over the year. Accounts show the finance costs of borrowing moved from £401,000 in 2024 to £1.4m in 2025.
The board subsequently cut the final dividend to 1.5p versus 2.65p the previous year.
Chair of the trust Roger Yates said investors should not invest in Pacific Horizon if ‘they require steady or growing income’ given the growth bias of the portfolio.
However, investors looking for capital returns have also been left wanting despite a rotation out of India and into China over the past 18 months.
China and Hong Kong both rose nearly 40% over the period as the government introduced huge stimulus packages and turned its attention to supporting the private sector.
Despite pushing into the right area, Pacific Horizon failed to share in the spoils of the Chinese recovery due to stock selection by Snell and Durrant, including an underweight in financials and not owning some of the top-performing technology companies such a e-commerce giant Alibaba and tech supplier Xiaomi.
The duo said they ‘added significantly to China’, most notably to internet platforms Meituan and Tencent, but also industrials, such as CATL, the world’s leading electric vehicle battery maker.
China now make up 36.4% of the portfolio, up from just over a quarter at the start of the period, and the managers said they ‘remain optimistic about the outlook for Asia’ given the ‘dramatic turnaround [in China], with equities rallying sharply from deeply depressed levels’.
‘Macroeconomic fundamentals are strong, valuations remain low, and sentiment in China is clearly improving,’ they said.
‘A weaker US dollar could act as a further tailwind for the region.’
Snell and Durrant said the investment case ‘remains compelling’ given valuations for high-quality companies are still low and households are flush with more than $10 trillion of savings since the Covid pandemic.
They predicted that on average, the holdings are forecast to grow earnings by 21.4% − more than double the benchmark index’s 9.2% − while still trading at a discount to market.
The majority of the portfolio may lie in China but Vietnam remains Snell and Durrant said Vietnam was ‘best structural growth story in Asia, underpinned by its successful export manufacturing base, and more recently, a powerful turnaround in the domestic cycle’.
Vietnam has also signed a ‘favourable’ trade deal with the US and any weakness caused by tariffs is ‘likely to be offset by a rapidly expanding domestic economy’.
They added to their holding in Military Commercial Joint Stock Bank and bought into Khang Dien Housing, a leading property developer.
Stocks in Asia may still be trading at a discount and so is PHI, which racked up an average discount of 11.9% over the year. This pushed the board to increase the number of buybacks, and in April it announced its intention to keep the discount in single digits.
Since then, it has averaged a 9.7% discount.
It repurchased 5m shares, or 5.5% of the share capital, at a cost of £29.8m over the year. Investors have also been promised a 25% tender offer if returns continue to disappoint.
Over three years, the fund is the second-worst performing trust in its six-strong Deutsche Numis Asia Pacific Equity sector with a NAV return of 21.8% and a share price returns of 19.5%.
Yates was optimistic about the potential for PHI and said ‘valuations look attractive and the recent headwinds of a strong US dollar and weak Chinese economic activity appear to be receding’.