Impax urges Saba to be ‘reasonable’ as it rejects tender offer
The chair of Impax Environmental Markets (IEM) has urged Saba Capital to be ‘reasonable’ in an open letter addressed to founder Boaz Weinstein, after the trust’s largest shareholder chose not to bow out via a tender offer.
The ‘continuation tender’ set out by Impax last month was offered at net asset value (NAV) less costs and had been reliant on Saba’s exit. While it was passed by shareholders at a general meeting on Monday, no tender election was received from the activist and the process has now been terminated.
In the letter, chair Glen Suarez highlighted that the vast majority of shareholders had signalled support for the current strategy and manager in a 2025 continuation vote. He said the tender was an attempt ‘to reconcile’ the differing views and interests of Saba and the rest of the shareholder base and ‘ensure that the company did not become enmeshed in an ongoing, destabilising and expensive dispute’, as seen elsewhere.
In a separate statement to shareholders, the board noted it had been in ongoing dialogue with Saba throughout the process, negotiating a ‘substantial financial contribution’ from the trust’s investment manager to better the terms.
Suarez’s letter also revealed that Saba had proposed the alternative ‘strategic’ option that Impax combine with another trust in which it has a large holding, with ‘an entirely different investment focus.’ Analysts have speculated this may have been Herald (HRI) – which presented a similar exit opportunity to Saba that was also rejected earlier this month.
‘I would urge you to be reasonable in your next steps,’ the chair said. The alternative option for Impax is now an ‘exit tender’, giving shareholders a final opportunity to exit at NAV less costs, rather than end up in a trust that could end up managed by the New York hedge fund.
‘You could tender in the exit tender offer, which would in effect destroy a UK listed company, or you could decide not to tender and take control,’ he said.
‘Both outcomes carry significant reputation risk for Saba – imposing an outcome the majority of our fellow shareholders to not wish to see,’ Suarez said, adding that Saba’s ‘pursuit of its own goals at the expense of all others’ should ultimately lead to policy changes in the UK which will ‘close investment strategy avenues’ for the activist.
Herald has already referred complaints about the activist to the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) this month, following the example of Edinburgh Worldwide (EWI) in January.
Joining this chorus, QuotedData’s James Carthew said the Impax story ‘illustrates the damage that anyone with more money than sense can do to the investment companies sector if left unchecked’.
He added: ‘It is time for the FCA to act. Clarifying the related-party rules, as Herald’s board has asked the FCA to do, would choke off Saba’s main line of attack - inserting directors it controls onto boards so that they can hand it the management contract. It may also be time for corporate advisers to dust off the rule book and explore legal avenues to insert poison pill defences into investment company structures. I hate that idea, but sometimes it is a case of the lesser of two evils.’
Impax is the last trust remaining in the Association of Investment Companies’ Environmental sector. Shares are up 16.3% over the past year, leaving its discount at 6.3%.
The Association of Investment Companies (AIC) has waded into the dispute between Saba and Impax, urging the former to ‘respect other shareholders’ views’ as a minority shareholder itself.
While Weinstein has positioned himself as a defender of shareholders, which he described as ‘mom and pop investors’, AIC chief executive Richard Stone said Saba was in fact ‘acting against the expressed wishes of other shareholders’.
‘The repeated rejection of tender offers at close to NAV shows that this is not about closing discounts. If he wants to take control of an investment trust, he should make an offer for other shareholders to consider,’ he said.
Saba’s refusal to exit share registers when given the option is putting boards in ‘an impossible position because its interests clearly do not align with other shareholders’, said Stone.
The AIC has, alongside individual trusts, called on the government and regulator to change the rules to ‘stop Saba exploiting the UK’s much admired listed company regime’.
‘Weinstein needs to do the decent thing and respect other shareholders’ views,’ he said.
Saba has since issued a statement saying it had been prepared to tender its shares on the condition Impax Asset Management first agree to pay the full tender costs for all shareholders wishing to exit, noting the board had been aware of this for several weeks.
It pointed out that on a three-year basis, IEM’s share price return of 4.9% lagged the benchmark by more than 54%.
‘Chairman Glen Suarez knows full well that all Impax Asset Management needed to do was say yes to paying the full tender costs and we would have participated – any claim otherwise is simply not true. For Saba, this decision was guided purely by our duty to hold management accountable to act in shareholders’ best interests by covering the costs of this exit,’ it said.
The chair had noted in his letter that Saba insisted it cover all the costs of the transaction including stamp duty but said this was ‘unreasonable, not workable and has never been done before.’